Home › Where to Eat › Best Italian Restaurants in Barrie
Best Italian Restaurants in Barrie

Best Italian Restaurants in Barrie

Curated guide featuring 7 outstanding restaurants, all rated 4.5+ stars

Home › Where to Eat › Best Italian Restaurants in Barrie

Barrie's Italian restaurant scene punches well above its weight, offering everything from old-school red-sauce comfort to contemporary Northern Italian elegance. What sets this city apart is the genuine passion behind these kitchens—many are family-run establishments where recipes have been handed down through generations, and others are helmed by chefs who've brought authentic regional techniques from Italy itself. Whether you're craving a perfectly charred Neapolitan pizza, homemade pasta that melts on your tongue, or a cozy trattoria atmosphere that transports you straight to Tuscany, Barrie delivers without the Toronto price tags or pretension.

This guide showcases 10 exceptional Italian restaurants that have earned their stellar reputations through consistently outstanding food and service. Every spot featured here has a rating of 4.5 stars or higher, backed by hundreds (sometimes thousands) of enthusiastic reviews. You'll find everything from bustling modern Italian bars perfect for date night to humble bakeries serving the city's best cannoli, plus intimate fine-dining destinations where every detail matters. Consider this your shortcut to the most memorable Italian meals in Barrie—no mediocre marinara or disappointing tiramisu in sight.

Featured Restaurants

Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Barrie
$$

Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Barrie

★★★★☆
4.8
(1,803 reviews)

This lively Italian kitchen and bar has won over locals and visitors alike with its welcoming atmosphere and consistently delicious Italian comfort food, earning an impressive 4.8-star rating from over 1,800 diners. Travelers rave about the generous portions and busy energy that make it perfect for both casual dinners and celebrations. Arrive early on weekends to snag a table without a wait, as this popular spot fills up quickly with families and groups looking for a reliably great meal.

129 Park Pl Blvd, Barrie, ON L4N 0L1, Canada
Fuda Italian Bakery
$$

Fuda Italian Bakery

★★★★☆
4.5
(1,531 reviews)

This beloved Barrie institution has earned its stellar reputation among over 1,500 reviewers who rave about its authentic Italian baked goods and welcoming neighborhood atmosphere. The combination of fresh-baked treats, quality grocery items, and convenient takeaway options makes it a local favorite for both quick stops and stocking up on Italian staples. Arrive early in the morning for the best selection of pastries straight from the oven, and don't leave without grabbing something for the road.

200 Wellington St W, Barrie, ON L4N 1K9, Canada
Il Buco
$$$

Il Buco

★★★★☆
4.7
(1,324 reviews)

Il Buco has earned its stellar reputation among Barrie locals and visitors alike, with over 1,300 glowing reviews praising its welcoming atmosphere and consistently excellent food across diverse menu offerings. This upscale spot delivers a refined dining experience without pretension, making it perfect for both special occasions and elevated everyday meals. Given its popularity and higher price point, reservations are highly recommended, especially for weekend evenings when this beloved establishment fills up quickly.

31 Dunlop St E, Barrie, ON L4N 1A2, Canada
Casa Mia Barrie
$$

Casa Mia Barrie

★★★★☆
4.5
(1,336 reviews)

Casa Mia Barrie has earned its stellar reputation among locals and visitors alike, with over 1,300 glowing reviews praising its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu options that cater to various tastes. Located right on Dunlop Street in the heart of downtown Barrie, this moderately priced gem consistently delivers quality food and service that keeps diners coming back. Given its popularity, consider making a reservation ahead of time, especially for weekend dinners when this beloved spot tends to fill up quickly.

88 Dunlop St W, Barrie, ON L4N 1A6, Canada
Michael & Marion's and The Side Door
$$

Michael & Marion's and The Side Door

★★★★☆
4.7
(895 reviews)

This beloved Barrie establishment has earned its stellar reputation with nearly 900 glowing reviews, offering a welcoming atmosphere where locals and travelers alike gather for consistently excellent food across varied menu options. The dual-concept setup with The Side Door provides flexibility whether you're looking for a refined dining experience or something more casual. With such high ratings at a reasonable price point, it's worth making a reservation ahead, especially on weekends when this popular spot fills up quickly.

89 Bayfield St, Barrie, ON L4M 3A7, Canada
147 Ristorante
$$

147 Ristorante

★★★★☆
4.5
(811 reviews)

Located in the heart of downtown Barrie, 147 Ristorante has earned its stellar reputation with over 800 glowing reviews, drawing both locals and visitors with its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu options. Diners consistently praise the quality and variety, making it a reliable choice whether you're craving comfort food or something more adventurous. With its mid-range pricing and prime Dunlop Street location, it's perfect for a leisurely lunch while exploring the downtown area or a satisfying dinner after a day by the waterfront.

147 Dunlop St E, Barrie, ON L4M 1A6, Canada
Paezano's Pizza & Marketplace
$

Paezano's Pizza & Marketplace

★★★★☆
4.6
(739 reviews)

Paezano's Pizza & Marketplace is a beloved Barrie gem that combines fresh-baked pizza with a convenient marketplace, making it perfect for grabbing a quick meal or stocking up on Italian groceries. With an impressive 4.6-star rating from over 700 reviews, travelers consistently praise the quality and value you get at this casual spot. Stop by during lunch hours for the freshest selections, and don't leave without exploring their bakery section for authentic Italian treats to take on the road.

35 Cedar Pointe Dr, Barrie, ON L4N 5R7, Canada

Culinary Experiences in Barrie

Discover food tours, cooking classes, and unique dining experiences